(From Dr. Jonathan Scott's Biology 215 class at Mount Union College, http://www.muc.edu/~scottjj/courses/bi215/finchquestions.htm)
Part One: Evolution in the Flesh (p. 3 – 112; suggested target: Sunday September 22)
1. What measurements do the Grants take on each finch?
2. How does Darwin describe natural selection?
3. Did Darwin ever observe natural selection in action?
4. Why are the finches on Daphne Island such an ideal population to study?
1. How many species of finch are found in the Galápagos?
2. Why are the Galápagos finches referred to as nature's "most famous toolkit?"
3. What hints do we have that Linné wondered about evolution?
4. How did Charles Lyell's Principles of Geology influence Darwin?
5. How did John Gould's discovery that there were 14 (13) species of finches on the Galápagos help spark Darwin's revolutionary ideas?
6. Why did Darwin begin the Origin with a detailed description of pigeon breeding?
1. Why might "Barnacle Bill" have been a good nickname for Charles Darwin?
2. What is Darwin's explanation for the lack of transitional forms between species?
3. Describe the large, medium, and small ground finches with respect to their beaks. What kind of adaptations do you think the finches' beaks represent?
4. How does the variation in populations of Darwin's finches compare with variation among populations of other birds, like sparrows?
1. Why did 19th and early 20th century biologists fail to recognize the importance of variation in beak size among Darwin's finches in the Galápagos?
2. How did David Lack's observation of the distribution of finch species in the Galápagos lead him to conclude that natural selection had indeed been at work?
3. What is a "McGill Nutcracker?"
4. How did the finches' feeding behavior change dirung the dry season?
1.How did the drought of 1977 affect the feeding behavior of finches on Daphne Island?
2. Why didn't the Grants and Peter Boag and Laurene Ratcliffe immediately recognize the episode of natural selection at work during the drought?
3. How did natural selection change the morphology of the finch populations on Daphne Island from 1977 to 1978?
1. Discuss the "costs and benefits" of black plumage among male Darwin's finches?
2. Provide a "cost-benefit analysis" of John Endler's guppies of South America with respect to their colorful spots.
3. Describe Endler's "natural" selection experiments with guppies. What did he show?
1.What was the selection response in the aftermath of El Niño on Darwin's finches?
2. How have biologists reconciled the apparent paradox of rapid evolution in the short term with much slower evolutionary rates measured in the fossil record?
3. Do the results on natural selection in Darwin's finches and British Columbian sparrows change your view of a species? If so, how?
Part Two: New beings on this Earth (p. 112 - 210; suggested target: Sunday September 29)
1. Compare the success of finch hybrids before the el niño of 1983 with those hatched afterwords.
1. Why was there so much debate over whether natural selection could give rise to new species?
1. What are Darwin's "incipient species?"
2. What is adaptive radiation?
3. How did Darwin imagine the "principle of divergence" would lead to new species?
4. What is meant by competitive exclusion? Character displacement?
5. How do Dolph Schluter's findings support the theory of character displacement?
1. What is is an "invisible coast"?
2. In what ways are species more "fluid" than even 20th century biologists might have believed? To what extent was Darwin's description of species as "convenient constructions" accurate? Are species real?
1. Do Benkman's and Lindholm's research on crossbills support the notion that gradual evolution can lead to the appearance of complex adaptations? Explain.
2. How are the stickleback fishes in British Columbian lakes studied by Dolph Schluter and John Donald McPhail similar to Darwin's finches?
1. How have the finch populations on Daphne Major responded to the changing adaptive landscape?
1. What role does inductive reasoning play in science?
Part Three: G.O.D. (p. 213 – 303; suggested target:
Sunday October 6)
1. What does Peter Boag hope to find by analyzing finch DNA?
1. Does the observation of haw flies and apple maggot flies support the notion of sympatric speciation? Explain.
1. What is introgressive hybridization and what role might it play in evolution?
1. What does Joshua Ledergerg mean when he says "Our only real competition for domination of the planet remains the viruses."?
1. What affect would global warming have on the ground finches of the Galápagos? Explain.
1. How has cultural evolution affected the success of our species?
1. What does Weiner mean when he suggests that "The thinking niche is taken..."?